I’ve decided that from now on, I’d like to be known as Lady M. I’d also like to have a button on the wall beside my bed that I could press upon awakening, a button that would bring forth a black and white uniformed maid proffering breakfast in bed on a silver tray. A maid on hand in the morning and again in the evening to dress me, arrange my hair and make my bed. After I was dressed in a corset that would work physiological wonders on my waistline, I would walk serenely into a well-appointed dining room and liveried footman would serve a three-course dinner upon a table for my own bacchanalian pleasure. I would rise after said repast and retire to the parlour to play cards and listen to conversation that would never venture beyond the weather and the latest goings on among our small circle of friends. At some point, a man most certainly resembling Dan Stevens would wander in and stare longingly at me from across the sumptuously furnished room.
Then I woke up and realised I don’t live in Downton Abbey. That I don’t live at Pemberley, Thornfield Hall, Wuthering Heights, Northanger Abbey, Mansfield Park or Rosings. For that matter, I don’t live in any bonnet drama. I live in a 40 square metre damp flat in the 18th arrondissement of Paris and live in the elasticised cocoon of a T-shirt and leggings everyday. My life is more of a Bother Drama. Which begs the question, why do I torture myself and watch these shows...over and over…and over again?
The sacred altar of the Bonnet Drama
Obsessed with the search for the divine truth in all things, as I am, I’ve actually tried to research this, both anecdotally and from within that font of recently blacked out knowledge, Wikipedia. In recent years, Downton Abbey has been the biggest thing on UK telly apart from the X-Factor so I’m not alone in my love of pretty dresses and well-mannered men.
Whether it is Austen, Dickens, Gaskell, any one of the prolific Brontës or their contemporary cousin, Julian Fellowes, Bonnet Dramas have that same soothing effect as a golden syrupy glass of after dinner Sauternes. At first glance it appears to be old and yellow and destined for those intellectually superior to oneself, but take that first sip, and alas, the sugary sweet haze takes over. You are lulled into a sense of sublime comfort and cloudy relaxation until that rude awakening when someone asks you to pay the bill, or in this case, the credits roll.
Hot and Heavy Heathcliff or Tom Hardy before he met Hollywood
A regimented world ordered by daily rhythms and unbreakable rules. A sex-divided world where women wear dresses and hats and gloves and embroidered shoes and perma-smiles. A world where upstairs and downstairs was the only class divide. A world where race and sex and colour described your horse. A world where the guy gets the girl and the girl knew it all along. A heap of steaming bulls**t that we have dreamt ourselves into while we are scrubbing last night’s dishes, or worse still scraping away yesterday’s fossilised mascara.
Unlike the reading of classical novels, where you are forced to look up the words you don’t know and your imagination is exercised as you mentally create the visages of each character, modern day Bonnet Dramas have no intellectual import. The language and the etiquette have been dumbed down for 21st Century audiences. People hug each other and say ‘Hi’ both inventions of today’s Americanised society. Kisses between heroes and heroines are rather more lingual than they might have been 150 years ago and situations like the ever present ‘entail’ must be explained for the modern viewer who has no property to inherit regardless of whether they are female.
I know Bonnet Dramas are the two-minute noodle of literary culture but I watch them all the same.
Richard Armitage pre-Hobbit as your Northern-bit-of-rough Mr Thornton
Mr Rochester brooding in front of the fire, Mr Thornton striding through the cotton mill, Captain Wentworth staring across at Anne in the music hall, Edward Ferrars fumbling his words, Darcy jumping into the lake and more recently Matthew Crawley on bended knee in the snow at Christmas. These are the starched collar romantic heroes a Modern Day Gal would lay down her waxed-legs-email-speed-dating-life for. Or at least we think we would.*
Staring into the handsome hero’s sultry eyes it is oh-so-easy to forget that were we to jump into Marty McFly’s Delorean and speed away into life in that sepia world, we would in exchange, have to forgo modern day luxuries such as toothpaste, Diet Coke, H&M and tampons. Shudder the thought!
Magnetic Magneto Michael Fassbender, Mr Rochester broods like no other
Contrary to popular belief, men watch bonnet dramas too. They just don’t readily admit to it. They also long for a time when the manliest challenge of their day might have been walking the dog. They wish for a world where they could don their favourite tweed jacket with the funky leather elbows (and not all ironic and Paul Smith) and shoot at defenceless game birds for fun. Most especially, they imagine a place where women shut their effing mouths and did what they were told, where marriage meant they were assured of healthy issue and a pretty face to entertain the party guests rather than the 21st century reality of shared housework, couples counselling and witnessing the birth of their child from that most intimate of feminine biological geographies.
And in 2012 we have the honest to goodness sultry stare of Dan Stevens - Matthew Crawley
Surveying friends, colleagues and family I have come to the conclusion that we long for the quiet order and bucolic simplicity of the places depicted in the Bonnet Drama.
In an increasingly chaotic world where the simplest of tasks have been mechanised and snap frozen, we wish we could take the time to actually cook something. Instead of texting or liking or tweeting we would welcome the opportunity to have face-to-face conversation with a lover and argue about something real rather than bitch about the snide comment his ex posted on his Facebook page. Rather than scanning the online profiles of a potential mate we want to be Lost In Austen’s Amanda. We want to be courted by a man who opens the door and kisses you sheepishly on the hand instead of groping your left one while he drunkenly shoves a hand inside your jeans.
Like all of life’s great questions, this isn’t an easy one to answer. If you don’t mind, I’ll spend the next few months puzzling over whether courtly love and sultry stares from a man in tight pants and a cravat, who is not gay, would be a fair exchange for the silky smooth cover of Tampax.
I’ll keep you posted.
* Yes people actually took time out of their lives and made all of these YouTube videos, so I am not the only sad person watching…